Growing Up Golem Read online

  Praise for Donna Minkowitz’s Ferocious Romance

  "Utterly entrancing … Donna Minkowitz introspects herself bare, and then with a breathtakingly fluent language of alternating waggery and sincerity, tells how she incorporated her doubts and certainties into that rarest thing: an authentic self. In this brilliantly funny, wise, joyful book, she achieves the compassion and depth that both the gay and right-wing movements profess to want, and fail to achieve: and she does so with a gentle lightness and forthright courage by which even a die-hard partisan would have to be swayed."

  — Andrew Solomon, author, Far from the Tree

  "An original, energetic and witty book.… Reveal[s] something meaty about real people with grace, humor, and intelligence."

  — Mary Gaitskill, the New York Observer

  "Donna Minkowitz's writing is a tonic."

  — Naomi Wolf

  "Original and provocative."

  — Susan Faludi

  "Infuriating, insightful, hilarious…. Deserves a wide readership among activists and right-wingers alike.”

  —Patrick Califia, author, Public Sex

  Growing Up Golem

  How I Survived My Mother, Brooklyn, and Some Really Bad Dates

  Copyright © 2013 by Donna Minkowitz

  Magnus Books, an Imprint of Riverdale Avenue Books

  5676 Riverdale Avenue, Suite 101

  Bronx, NY 10471

  All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, without permission in writing from the publisher.

  Printed in the United States of America

  First Edition

  Cover by: Paul Chamberlain/Cerebral Itch Creative

  Digital and Interior Layout by www.formatting4U.com

  Design by:

  Print ISBN: 978-1-936833-60-3

  Digital ISBN: 978-1-936833-74-0

  www.riverdaleavebooks.com

  For Steven Fetherhuff, who taught me literally how to stand up straight,

  and Irving Kizner, who taught me how to do it figuratively

  Everything in this book is true, except the parts concerning magic and time travel.

  Most names and some identifying details have been changed.

  I may know a very little about Gnosticism, but I am no scholar of it. And alas, I am most certainly no expert on the Kabbalah, alchemy, or Jewish religion. I apologize for any inadvertent errors.

  "The Human-stories of the elves are doubtless full of the Escape from Deathlessness."

  — J.R.R. Tolkien, On Fairy-Stories

  Chapter One

  My mother loved to make things. One day, when I was thirty-two, my mother created a giant, half-life-size doll that looked just like me. (This is absolutely true.) It had yarn hair the same color and kink as mine, and real corduroy pants just like the ones I wear. My mother called it the Dyke Donna doll. (Mom was very pro-gay and lesbian, so she always felt very happy using words like "dyke.") The doll wore a stripey red shirt like a circus performer, along with real, removable, bright red booties made of felt, and extravagantly long curling eyelashes that my mother drew in by hand, quite lovingly. It had big red apple blush-marks on its cheeks, like Pinocchio as I have always seen him drawn. It stood a discomfiting three feet tall (I myself am only five feet two). My mother gave it to me as her gift, to keep in my tiny apartment. I had to keep it under my bed because I couldn’t bear to see it sitting in my chair. But I felt like I was hiding a child away there, without food or anyone to talk to.

  Starting in her early 20s, my mother had made a whole series of dolls and wooden soldiers and little straw figurines and puppets, and I believe that one of them was me. A few years after the Dyke Donna doll appeared, my arms broke. (This, also, is true.) I don’t mean that my arm bones broke—I’ve never had a broken bone—but that my arms’ capacity as limbs, their functionality and coherence, suddenly ended.

  It was as though my hands had simply stopped being hands. They began to hurt so badly that I didn't want to do anything with them, because that only made them hurt more.

  I was a writer. I am a writer. And it hurt to write, just like anything else people do with their hands, which basically destroyed me. But forget about “me" and my twee artiness and ridiculous ego— please just forget, reader!—because what I’m really afraid of telling you about, really, really afraid, is the pain. The pain from that time, when it began, thirteen years ago, still seems magical to me, as though it could happen again at any moment. Just by thinking about it.

  As I write—with voice dictation software, the only way I can from now on—it’s almost happening again. I couldn’t lie about how scared I am of this, it would make me vomit. My hands start to feel as though they’re rolling in rocks…

  A mysterious tension in my arms, like a salt battery beginning to work.

  It hurt, that March it started, in my upper back, shoulders, forearms, wrists, hands and neck. Sometimes even my head, by means of a process I couldn’t begin to comprehend. Sometimes it burned, as though hot metal were in my shoulders. The hands were the worst, with knives sticking in the palms. I had a sensation of spears through the wrists. Had I suddenly become a Christian martyr? But the pain wasn’t even agreeably sexual, as it might have been if I’d turned into Saint Sebastian. It was impossible to aestheticize it without—begging your pardon— throwing up. The backs of my hands felt as though they were being repeatedly forced to move through a basin full of tiny, crushed metal balls, like in some Star Trek punishment from a newly-contacted planet.

  This happened suddenly. I was having sex with a married woman—well, a woman married to another woman, and occupied as well with two small children—when my attack occurred.

  All right, I wasn’t in the very act of having sex with her when it happened—God does not work in such linear-narrative ways. And, if you’re wondering why my attack occurred, why God caused it, they weren’t precisely, absolutely married—in point of fact, they had an open relationship. But almost—I was almost in the very moment of having sex with her, and they were very nearly married, except that they had sex with other people. I don’t even believe in a punitive God. I don’t even believe that “things happen for a reason”!

  But it happened. And I couldn’t tell why. It was around Purim, and everything in my life had stopped making sense. I went to a lecture at Makor, a conventional yet profound and funky Jewish center—I live in New York City, where we have such things—called “Stop Making Sense—Purim’s Radical Message.”

  It turned out to be a sort of class, led by a strangely left-leaning Orthodox rabbi. I remember that I couldn’t raise my hands in the class because it hurt. The pain had begun just that week. I was trying not to worry about it too much, although I had a peculiar presentiment that my life had changed. I asked the young guy sitting next me to raise his hand for me when I wanted to talk. I flirted with a nice woman in the next row who turned out to be from my neighborhood, beautiful Park Slope, Brooklyn. The rabbi was talking about how every Jew was required to get so drunk on Purim that they couldn’t tell Mordecai, the one who saved us all in this story, from Haman, the one who tried to exterminate us.

  Now, Purim has always been my favorite Jewish holiday because it is a holiday about catastrophe—only the Jews would be crazy and brave enough to have a holiday about catastrophe, tragedy, trauma itself. On Purim you were supposed to dress in costume, get drunk off your ass—the Orthodox guy was only stating basic Jewish law to us—and act psychotic, because you were so freaked out that some people had long ago tried to kill you.

  That morning, I'd decided to break up with Gemma, the woman with the frolicsome partner and the kids, who had said to me yearningly the first t
ime she kissed me, “I want to give you pain!” The yearning quality had surprised me, moved me. Gemma's voice was blonde, like unfiltered honey, and it had a crazy warmth to it. I'd decided to break up with Gemma, but to have one last date, one final cataclysmic ending with her, before we did.

  But I was sad—oh, reader, even though I was the one doing the breaking up, even though Gemma was a thoroughly modern girl whonever got emotional about women and I was trying hard to be one, too, someplace so far away I couldn’t taste it I was very, very sad.

  My mother, who was pretty cataclysmic or catastrophic in her own right, had been about to die for decades, and was finally, anticlimactically doing it. ("Your mom’s dying?” my friend Harry asked when I told him, a year and a half before she actually did, as it happened. He rolled his eyes at me theatrically. “Um, you told me that three years ago!”) My mother had begun telling us she was dying around 1972. An operation that she’d had for cancer of the larynx, when I was seven, had been a great success, although it left her with a large, permanent opening in her neck that she referred to conversationally as "my hole.” She breathed through it. It looked a little bit bloody, but she would cover it with baby-napkin bibs or flowered scarves.

  The hole worked pretty well, but she said it left her vulnerable to breathing a lot of “particulate matter,” which causes asthma and emphysema. And so my mother had begun planning her funeral when I was still at PS 197, choosing a guest list and announcing what works of literature should be read aloud (she particularly wanted me to read a long Kurt Vonnegut excerpt that began, "God made mud.”). She wanted classy food to be served, like dark chocolates and champagne. Later, as we entered a new millennium, my sister Josie and I had a "dying party” with her one evening, when she was certain she would go that night. I brought her favorite foods, wine spritzers and a hot fudge sundae, and we sang to her. The dying had started when I was eight; I was now pushing forty.

  In addition to my mother’s being finally (maybe) ready to pass, other anticlimaxes had been bursting out all over my life. I had just broken up what I’d considered a marriage, to a gay man by whom I not only never got shtupped, but usually didn't get my phone calls returned. Perhaps this was a series of crumbly anticlimaxes, because just before that, Edna, my therapist of twelve years, had suddenly dumped me. She said she’d just realized that our therapy wasn’t working.

  And then my arms suddenly fell apart, too. They had lost their ability to do much more than flap.

  My first book had come out—to poor sales, naturally, although my editor had said the book would make me "the next Susan Faludi”—just before Edna ditched me. Before that I’d left the Village Voice, my sole and tightly-gripped foothold in the writing world, because they had promised to make me an official, salaried staff writer and had gone back on it. (This was the good Village Voice of years ago, reader—pardon me for saying so!—not the current one.) Me, I had slipped into the Voice at the age of twenty-two and snuck, wormed, even stolen my way into writing for them. Why else would the paper I believed in more than any other publication in the country publish me? I wasn’t a real person, and I knew it. I have always been a makeshift, artificial person, like a scary marionette or a ventriloquist’s dummy, and I have always known I would be found out someday and punished for my evil dissimulation.

  I have known I was a magical being, hand-crafted rather than born, from my earliest days. I’m not sure when I first found out, but it goes back at least to the timemy mother, when I was four, began telling me and my sisters that she herself could perform magic, could make us do whatever she wanted, like puppets.

  She also could tell whatever we were thinking.

  My great-grandmother, a Romanian Jew, knew the "gypsy signs” that could tell you what was about to happen—say, by looking at a frozen tree or a dead animal found by the river, and other potent pagan peasant magics that she taught my mother. My great-grandfather, a Jew from Austria, taught my mom wild Hasidic magics that he’d quietly mined from Kabbalah and Martin Buber.

  My mother was an extraordinarily— at times revoltingly—creative person, so it was no great stretch to believe she had shaped me like a golem or a living toy,embedded with unnatural life-force like a hobgoblin conjured from a stale half-brownie and a brittle, faded page or two of Keats or Shelley.

  Have you ever heard of golems, the source of my mother’s first, simple recipe, reader? Oh goyische or unmystical, read here: golems are artificial persons that learned sixteenth century rabbis made out of wet clay, to do everything their makers told them to, and to attack the people who were lynching Jews all over Eastern Europe. They were all eventually snuffed out by their creators, except me. I survived my mother.

  My mother added a few special items to theclay that she’d begun with, no doubt because she wanted to be fancy. I had polyurethane in me, I could tell, and psychically potent bits of tin and panty and old paper that she’d discovered at garage sales and a vintage store. Some paint-encrusted nails, chipped tiny screws. Dirty rags that she did not wash, so that their previous owners’ human perfumes might waft through me and provide a power of their own. A few crumbs of wet muffin. I have tried for years to find out exactly what she assembled on her kitchen floor before she said that ridiculous mix of Hebrew and Coptic words. Even now, almost everything I’ve said is guesswork. (Did she cut her fingernails at least to make some protein and collagen to go into me?)

  It was the 1960s, generally too early for cybernetics, but my mother was a brilliant woman and well aware of Alan Turing’s theories, and she may have put an early self-aware chip in me. (If so, the first and second laws of robotics would require that it did not displace the pagan magics constituting me, but added to them.)

  Golems (and robots) are but two species of our kind, of course. Many clumps of mud on several continentshave been over-stimulated with unnatural spirit this way, by persons of power like my mother, for millennia. Certain rocks and springs have been galvanized (for eons) with a painful awareness, and there are young girls (and boys) imprisoned in eleven-inch Barbie dolls, living spirits imprisoned in bottle caps, baseball and tarot cards smarting and throbbing inside locked-up collections. Puppets and toys created far, far realer than they should be. Trees twisted with the force of something alien inside them. We are all over the world, we half-human sad, impregnated, lonely things, sung into life by magicians and pallid Hasids and evil PhDs who wanted to try and see—just try and see! they had wild hopes—if they could reproduce themselves without a partner.

  The alchemists made their own little people out of chicken eggs mixed with human blood or sperm, bits of skin, occasionally animal hair or feathers. Sometimes dung (for who has not wished, at least once in their lives, to create a world out of their dung?) Other makers formed their creatures out of wood, or straw, or plastic that was enchanted so that it could think on its own, walk about, and have wishes.

  I was one of these subtly manufactured little persons, one that canny old artist my mother had made, and I found her work in the stool-like shaping of myself—oh mother, forgive me!—disgusting.

  When I was a child, she put her own art up in the kitchen, but never mine or my sisters’. She made male, earth-red masks from papier-mâché, fierce and staring, extraordinary. A painting that scared me (and I loved) of a tree with branches like claws, surrounded by a crying storm (“Mommy was having a very bad day when she made that.”). A weird clown that looked like my father, sad and falsely smiling(“It’s Daddy!” we cried happily). A still life of sensual apple, grapes, and pear that I thought was the most beautiful thing I would ever see, and how amazing that I could see it every day while eating my peanut butter and jelly. A bad primitive watercolor of bleak houses and a tree by a lake. I thought all her art was genius then. Her output was prodigious. There wasa needlepoint of her own face that depicted her as accurately as a photograph but also made her look exactly like the Virgin Mary.

  Years later, there was a wild, abstract sculpture of her lungs, constructed of clear
plastic tubing, with Aeolus, the god of the winds—a clay figure—attempting to breathe into them. (She was dying of lung disease.) A sexy, disturbing, luscious, Chinese-looking painting of a red rooster menacing a hen.

  Then there was her writing. A ferocious story narrated by an insane boy who saw light all around him in wave form—I was eight, and it remains my favorite work by her. Her master’s thesis on Feuerbach and Hegel—I was nine and I loved it, although I didn’t know what "hermeneutics” were. Her dissertation on whether a Marxist philosophical framework might possibly allow for religion—I loved that, too, at fourteen, and was crushed when, at sixteen, she decided that her dissertation committee was too politically conservative to ever allow her to actually get her PhD on that topic, and so she transferred to Teachers College to produce a much tamer and more boring dissertation about Marxist pedagogy. I read all the drafts of all versions of the thesis and dissertation, and proofread them all, plus her translation from the Latin of Lucretius (my age: ten), and her undergrad Urban Planning paper (six) on the unique water supply of New York City. Don’t even get me started on her poems.

  I admired all of her art but I hated admiring it because it was always there, and it took up all our space. I also hated admiring it because my mother made me admire it, telling me her work was wonderful until it was the beginning and end of what I thought wonderful was.

  When I was six, my mother asked if I wanted to be Haman for Purim and I thought that was a fantastically wonderful idea as well, because I had never been Haman and neither the girls nor boys had ever been him in my school; the girls were always Queen Esther in tinfoil crowns and kitchen-drapery ball gowns. I hated being Queen Esther, and I loved the idea of being someone evil.